In partnership with
Your competitors' reviews are not only about your competitors.
They are also a public record of what customers praise, what frustrates them, what they worry about, and which details influence their decisions.
You should never copy a competitor's review or present it as your own. You can, however, study recurring themes and create original content that explains how your own business handles those situations.
Today, you are going to find ten useful content ideas without staring at a blank page.
⚡ IN THIS ISSUE
Find useful themes in positive and negative competitor reviews
Record customer problems, questions, fears, and desired results
Convert one research session into ten original post ideas
Use your own experience instead of copying a competitor
Avoid turning useful research into a public attack
Take the prompts our creative team actually uses
The key to maintaining brand quality at scale? Mastering how to communicate with AI models and embedding them into your creative strategy.
Join our honest discussion with Ari Murray, Chief Digital Officer at Salt and Stone, and get 5 tips for expert LLM prompting with ready to run prompts.
🔬 TODAY'S FIELD TEST
MINE TWO COMPETITORS' REVIEWS
Choose two established competitors that serve the same general customer.
Read approximately ten recent reviews for each business. Include positive, average, and negative reviews when available.
You are not trying to decide whether the competitor is good or bad. You are looking for patterns in what customers care about.
Create a simple document with four columns:
Review theme | What the customer cared about | Question we can answer | Our own experience or process |
|---|---|---|---|
Unexpected cost | Knowing the price before approving work | What is included in our estimate? | Explain our estimate and approval process |
Slow updates | Knowing what happens next | How often do we communicate? | Show our actual communication schedule |
Clean work area | Respect for the customer's property | How do we protect the space? | Demonstrate our real cleanup process |
Do not copy the review into your marketing document unless you need a short note for private research. Record the theme and the customer's concern in your own words.
📘 WANT THE COMPLETE LOCAL VISIBILITY SYSTEM?
The five-minute fix improves one important channel. The Local Business Visibility Blueprint shows how to build the entire system: Google, your website, reviews, social media, directories, AI search, paid advertising, and a practical 30-day action plan.
The Blueprint is normally $47.99 - NOW on sale for $27.99!
GET YOURS HERE
📡 SIGNAL CHECK
Business owners often create content about the subjects they find interesting. Customers are usually focused on more immediate questions:
How much will this cost?
How long will it take?
Can I trust this person?
What happens after I call?
Will the business explain my options?
What if something goes wrong?
Has the business handled my situation before?
Reviews expose these questions because customers describe the moments that affected their experience.
Positive reviews show what customers value. Negative reviews reveal expectations, fears, and sources of frustration. Average reviews often contain the most useful mixture: the customer explains what worked and what could have been clearer.
Your job is not to use a competitor's weakness against them. Your job is to understand the market and explain your own service more clearly.
How Jennifer Aniston’s LolaVie brand grew sales 40% with CTV ads
For its first CTV campaign, Jennifer Aniston’s DTC haircare brand LolaVie had a few non-negotiables. The campaign had to be simple. It had to demonstrate measurable impact. And it had to be full-funnel.
LolaVie used Roku Ads Manager to test and optimize creatives — reaching millions of potential customers at all stages of their purchase journeys. Roku Ads Manager helped the brand convey LolaVie’s playful voice while helping drive omnichannel sales across both ecommerce and retail touchpoints.
The campaign included an Action Ad overlay that let viewers shop directly from their TVs by clicking OK on their Roku remote. This guided them to the website to buy LolaVie products.
Discover how Roku Ads Manager helped LolaVie drive big sales and customer growth with self-serve TV ads.
The DTC beauty category is crowded. To break through, Jennifer Aniston’s brand LolaVie, worked with Roku Ads Manager to easily set up, test, and optimize CTV ad creatives. The campaign helped drive a big lift in sales and customer growth, helping LolaVie break through in the crowded beauty category.
🧪 THE EXPERIMENT:
FIND TEN IDEAS IN 20 MINUTES
MINUTES 0–5: COLLECT REPEATED THEMES
Read the positive reviews first.
Write down repeated themes such as:
fast response
clear explanations
accurate estimates
professional staff
easy scheduling
clean work
strong communication
patience
local knowledge
a result that exceeded expectations
Do not assume that a commonly praised feature is unique. Treat it as evidence that customers care about that feature.
MINUTES 5–10: STUDY SOURCES OF FRICTION
Now read the lower-rated reviews.
Look for:
unanswered calls
confusing prices
missed deadlines
unclear next steps
unexpected charges
poor follow-up
difficulty scheduling
a difference between the promise and the result
questions the customer says were never answered
You are looking for content opportunities—not gossip.
If several reviews mention confusing estimates, create a post that explains how estimates work in your industry and what your own estimate includes. Do not write, “Unlike our competitors, we do not surprise you.” Explain your process without naming or insulting anyone.
MINUTES 10–15: CAPTURE CUSTOMER LANGUAGE
Notice the ordinary words customers use to describe their problems.
A professional may say cash-flow forecasting while a customer says, “I make sales, but I never know where the money went.” A real estate professional may say pre-listing preparation while a homeowner says, “I do not know what to fix before we sell.”
Use the customer's plain-language problem as the subject of your content. Do not copy a distinctive sentence or personal story from a review. Translate the recurring concern into your own words and answer it with your own knowledge.
MINUTES 15–20: CREATE TEN HEADLINES
Use one theme with each of these formulas:
Answer a repeated question: “What Is Included in a [Service] Estimate?”
Explain what happens next: “What Happens After You Book Your First Appointment?”
Prevent a common mistake: “Three Mistakes to Avoid Before [Customer Action]”
Reduce a common fear: “Worried About [Concern]? Here Is How the Process Works”
Clarify the timeline: “How Long Does [Service] Usually Take?”
Show your process: “How We Protect Your [Home, Time, Records, or Investment]”
Help customers compare: “Five Questions to Ask Before Hiring a [Professional]”
Explain a cost: “Why [Service] Prices Vary—and What Affects Your Quote”
Share your own case study: “How We Helped a Customer Handle [Common Situation]”
Create a checklist: “Before You Call a [Professional], Gather These Four Things”
You now have ten posts. You do not need to write all ten today. Choose the headline that answers the most repeated or urgent concern and create that one first.
A PRACTICAL EXAMPLE: THE HVAC COMPANY
Imagine that an HVAC company studies reviews of several businesses in its market. The owner repeatedly sees customers mention:
uncertainty about diagnostic fees
waiting without an arrival update
technicians who explain several repair options
concern about keeping the home clean
confusion about whether a repair is urgent
The company could create these original posts:
What Our Diagnostic Visit Includes
What Happens Between Booking and Arrival
Repair, Monitor, or Replace? How We Explain the Options
How Our Technicians Protect Floors and Work Areas
Three HVAC Problems That Should Not Wait
Three Problems That May Not Be Emergencies
Why Repair Quotes Can Change After Inspection
Five Questions to Ask Before Approving a Major Repair
What Information Helps Us Diagnose a Problem Faster
What to Expect After the Repair Is Complete
Those ideas came from market research, but the finished posts must describe the company's real services, real policies, and real experience.
If the company does not provide arrival updates, it should not write a post implying that it does. The review research may reveal an operational improvement that should happen before the marketing claim.
THE FOUR-PART ORIGINALITY TEST
Before publishing a post inspired by review research, check four things:
1. THE WORDING IS YOURS
Do not copy a competitor's review, headline, or response. Write the post from a blank page using the general theme.
2. THE EXPERIENCE IS YOURS
Use a situation your business actually handled, a process your team actually follows, or advice you genuinely give customers.
3. THE PROOF IS YOURS
If the post includes a result, testimonial, photograph, statistic, or case study, it must come from your own business or be properly attributed to a reliable source.
4. THE CLAIM IS TRUE
Do not promise same-day service, fixed prices, constant updates, or guaranteed outcomes unless your business actually provides them.
Competitor reviews identify subjects. They do not supply your proof.
WHAT NOT TO DO
Do not name the competitor in your content.
Do not quote a competitor's unhappy customer as an advertisement.
Do not contact reviewers to sell your services.
Do not copy a competitor's response to a review.
Do not exaggerate another business's mistake.
Do not pretend that a competitor's customer was your customer.
Do not build your entire message around being “better” than someone else.
Customers do not need a public argument. They need a clear answer to the problem that caused them to search.
TURN THE RESEARCH INTO A MONTH OF CONTENT
Publish two or three of the ideas each week.
Mix the formats:
one short face-to-camera video
one checklist graphic
one Google Business Profile post
one website FAQ
one customer email
one detailed article
After publishing, note which subjects produce questions, messages, website visits, calls, or appointments. That response becomes your next round of customer research.
The goal is not merely to fill a calendar. It is to make your marketing more useful and easier for customers to understand.
🎯 BEFORE YOU CLOSE THIS EMAIL
Choose two competitors. Read twenty reviews. Record the repeated problems, questions, fears, and desired results. Then use the ten headline formulas to write your first ten ideas.
Create only one post today. Make it the post that answers the clearest customer question with your own experience.
Then reply and tell me what you found. Which customer question appeared most often? What would you like help turning into your next post?
Your answer may become the next Visibility Science field test.
Bottom line: Your competitors' reviews can show you what the market cares about, but your own knowledge, process, and proof must create the final content.
❓ WHAT DO YOU NEED HELP WITH?
We want Visibility Science to help with the marketing problems you are actually facing—not the ones marketers assume you have.
Reply to this email and tell us:
What part of marketing do you need help with right now?
What have you been trying to figure out?
What would you like me to explain or show you in a future issue?
It can be a broad question or one very specific problem. Your reply may help shape one of the next experiments we work through together.
Marketing engineered for business growth.
Till next time,